Best Pizza in Peoria, AZ | Don's NY Pizza & Wings

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Peoria, AZ at 7539 W Peoria Ave

Authentic New York-Style Pizza & Slices in Peoria

Thin crust, rich sauce, freshly shredded gooey mozzarella — Proudly Serving Peoria, Glendale, and the West Valley, made the way New Yorkers actually expect it. Dine in, pick up, or get it delivered.

Order Now

Beyond the Pie: Now featuring our new Apple Strudel Pizza Pie!!! Wings, Cheesesteaks, Calzones

Don’s NY Pizza is a family-owned pizza shop serving authentic New York-style pizza, loaded Philly cheesesteaks, crispy wings, fresh calzones, and classic comfort food made with quality ingredients and big flavors. From hand-tossed pizzas to hearty sandwiches, Don’s brings a true East Coast taste to every meal.

See the Full Menu

Featured

View menu

Fresh Out of the Oven

Don's NY Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join Don's NY Pizza Rewards

Where New York Meets the West Valley

Welcome to Don's NY Pizza in Peoria, AZ—your spot for classic New York–style pies with foldable, hand‑tossed crusts, zesty sauce, and melty mozzarella. Build your perfect pizza or choose from our house specialties, plus jumbo slices, wings, salads, and oven‑baked sides. Order online for quick pickup or local delivery, or stop in for friendly dine‑in service. From game night to weeknight dinners, Don's NY Pizza brings big‑city flavor to the West Valley.

Ready To Reserve Your Spot?

Make a reservation and settle into a booth, catch the game, or stop by for a quick pickup. We’re conveniently located on West Peoria Avenue and ready to welcome you whenever you’re in.

Pizza is amazing honestly. If Dave portnoy came here he would give this place a solid 7.5 to 7.9 it’s not in the 8s. But it’s definitely worthy of a try. I’ve eaten NY pizza since I was a kid all the time. This pizza really reminds me of ny pizza in a way. The taste is nostalgic. Atmosphere is eh. People are friendly here and serve you without attitude. I’ve come here so many times and I have never been let down on a regular cheese slice.

Jose M.

We just happened to drive by and see Dons and stopped in. It was fantastic, the food was delicious and quick. The manager was so welcoming and helpful. My son dropped his ketchup and antonio cleaned it for us with a smile. The overall experience was so good, we will be back again! Antonio and the staff made the experience a 10/10

Tamara H.

This pizza was so tasty and good. I went here after work to bring dinner home for my family. Authentic NY Pizza Place! Nice and friendly staff. Kid friendly! I will be coming back really soon. My family loved the pizza!

We really enjoy good pizza and i wish we had more quality pizza here in AZ but many in Az think Pizza hut is legit, like the folks in Iowa that think Taco Bell is authentic mexican food. Having eaten NY pizza in NY, this is banging! You know you have great pizza when every person eats every bit of crust with fresh slices still in the box. Their bread is awesome, which makes a great pie. Cheese seemed legit and the sauce was great.

Philip K.